Restaurants

Otto's

4.4 224 reviews 05:00 AM - 09:00 PM 2514 NY-52, Liberty, NY 12754, United States

Discover this place

Located at 2514 NY-52 in Liberty, NY, Otto's has rapidly become a beloved dining destination for locals and visitors alike. Patrons have raved about the impressive menu, where standout dishes like the veal piccata and mushroom agnolotti have garnered significant acclaim. The warmth of the experience is amplified by the chef/owner's personal touch in engaging with guests, creating a welcoming atmosphere.

Reviews highlight the restaurant's exceptional service, with diners appreciating the attentive yet unhurried pace, allowing them to savor each bite. One reviewer, Jill B, declared Otto's Caesar salad the best she’s ever had, while others have echoed sentiments about the superb oysters and wine selection. Customer feedback reflects a cozy ambiance that pairs perfectly with the high-quality cuisine.

For those seeking a fine dining experience without the city hustle, Otto's shines as a hidden gem comparable to upscale establishments in New York City. As Greg Spektor aptly noted, discovering this culinary treasure might make future reservations a challenge, but it’s a risk worth taking. With such a delightful menu and passionate service, dining at Otto's promises a fabulous gastronomic journey.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fireplace
Sports

Dining options

Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Otto's before visiting.

Reviews for Otto's

4.4

224 reviews

100%

23%

11%

10%

Review highlights

Based on 224 reviews

Otto's has established a strong reputation for delivering consistently high-quality food that rivals fine dining standards, particularly noted for dishes like veal piccata and chicken Marsala. Reviewers frequently highlight the fresh, flavorful offerings and commend the restaurant’s ability to cater to both casual lunches and more relaxed, unhurried dining experiences. The atmosphere is described as cozy and inviting, enhanced by attentive yet unobtrusive service that allows guests to enjoy their meals at a comfortable pace. Additionally, the personal attention from the chef/owner adds a unique and appreciated touch. Otto’s also stands out for its well-curated drink and wine selection, including rare offerings such as quality oysters. Overall, the brand is praised for maintaining a warm ambiance, excellent customer care, and a culinary experience that consistently delights locals and visitors alike.

Patrick O'Sullivan

Jun 30, 2025

We stopped in here today for Lunch, food was delicious and we thought it was a lovely personal touch that the chef/ owner stopped by all the tables. Veal piccata Make sure give this place a try!! ...

Jill B

May 31, 2025

The best Caesar salad I’ve ever had. The chicken Marsala was delicious.

Ashley Weigelt

May 21, 2025

Food was perfect & great service. I love how I did not feel rushed, the service was perfectly attentive without rushing. I like to take my time & relax while dining. The veal piccata was delicious. Fabulous time.

paulina hospod

May 13, 2025

We really enjoyed the food, drinks and wine. One if few places in the area with good oysters. The place is also really cozy and service is superb. I highly recommend it.

Greg Spektor

May 04, 2025

I almost hesitate to write this review because the more people discover this gem the harder it’ll be to get a reservation. We’ve been coming here since before Covid and this restaurant seems to have gone unscathed. In fact, they took the opportunity to move to a space that’s as beautiful as their food is delicious. The food here is on par with some of the best fine dining establishments in NYC. The service is good. They don’t schedule reservations back to back like a restaurant recently did to us. If you have the opportunity to visit have the mushroom agnolotti. They are unreal!

Eddie B

Apr 20, 2025

What a wonderful dinner my wife and I had at Piccolo Paese on Friday night. We had made reservation for 5:15, but truly didn't need them at that time. The restaurant has a warm, simplistic decor, but it is also very quaint and inviting. Our servers (Edith and Lily) were wonderful and were on top of everything. They started by bringing us water along with a bowl of warm bread and a very flavorful olive oil. For an appetizer we split an order of clams oreganata and then I had Linguini Puttanesca, and my wife the Tortellini Gratin. Both dishes were large portions and extremely tasty! At the conclusion of our meal, the owner approached our table and enquired how everything was. I felt it was a very nice touch and something most owner no longer do. If in the area of Liberty, NY, or if you are visiting Resorts World Casino, Piccolo Paese in only a short drive away and absolutely worth the trip!

J. Gilbert

Apr 14, 2025

Went to Otto's for the happy hour oysters and cocktails. Oysters were perfect with mignonette sauce. Also had the calamari that was lightly breaded and delicious. Sat at the bar, which has a nice view of the gold course. Great service. In checking out what other patrons were eating, everything looked tasty. I was told there was a new chef, and it is clearly a very positive change. Looking forward to our next visit!

Adrienne Snobeck

Apr 02, 2025

Beautifully redone inside. Bright & inviting. Had the hot honey peach margarita, which was delicious. Menu had loads of options, but kept it simple when ordering for our first time there - Favorites were the wings & classic mussels